More Super Bowl life lessons

I've done a "Super Bowl Life Lessons" column for the last few years and, to be honest, I'm beginning to wonder if the Super Bowl as a cultural spectacle has all that much more to teach us. Guys are still oafs. Violence is still funny (especially so when it involves sumo wrestlers). Talking flowers and babies are still funny. Classic rockers are still old. The main innovation this year seems to be that guys not wearing pants is funny.
Perhaps the lesson this year is from the football game itself. Often, the Super Bowl teaches us that the powerful will crush the weak in an excessive display of might over helplessness (see San Francisco and Dallas wins in the 1990s). However, the aughts have reminded us that the mighty are sometimes laid low (see losses by the early Rams, the late Patriots and the Colts not even making it most years).
This year's lesson was especially poignant though, in how it demonstrated that winning a Super Bowl can provide housing and hurricane protection for an entire city. Oh wait, no that's not it. Winning a Super Bowl can make you forget how you were abandoned in your time of need? No? You don't have to actually help a ravaged city if you root for their football team? I'm sure there's a lesson in there - help me out here.
The good news, though, even for Colts fans, is that an NFC team won, thus guaranteeing that our economy will bounce back this year, as the old urban legend says. If only the Cardinals had beaten the Steelers last year, then the economy would be going great, people would not be so freaked out by the deficit, and we'd have some kind of health insurance reform by now. Stinkin' Steelers.
Anyway, now I'm boring you with talk of football and politics. Let's get to the commercials. Here's the most highly anticipated one:
Oops. So much for trying to get off politics. The big surprise of the night was that Tim Tebow's mom did not talk about abortion, at least not directly. CBS has had a long standing policy of not airing controversial issues ads during the Super Bowl. For example, this 2004 commercial had the controversial message that gays are welcome at the United Church of Christ. It was not allowed on the air:
This year, they also rejected this (albeit cheesy) ad for Man Crunch, a gay dating site. It mostly looks like guys pretending to make out:
However, CBS changed their policy this year when they said they would allow Focus on the Family to air an anti-abortion ad featuring Tim Tebow's mom. The ad was to say she was pressured to have an abortion when she lived in the Philippines in the late 1980s. However, they apparently changed their minds again, since the ad ended up just saying that Tim Tebow's mom is proud of her son and that "she almost lost him." I almost lose my children every time we go to a big box store, so there's nothing controversial about that. This was probably a wise move on the Tebow's part, since there are some questions about the veracity of their story, given it was highly illegal to have an abortion in the Philippines at the time of Timmy's birth.
So, without controversial issue ads to muddy the water, we are left with the usual smattering of cultural lessons. My take is as follows:
Tackling old people is funny (Betty White and Abe Vigoda, especially): Snickers, Focus on the Family
KISS is funny. Mini-KISS is even funnier: Dr. Pepper
People will only help others if they can get something in return, like beer: Budweiser
The 1985 Chicago Bears still dance badly, but now they are old too: Boost Mobile
Although men can't pretend to make-out, they don't have to wear pants anymore: Dockers, Coke, Career Builder
Gay men are allowed in commercials as long as they slap each other in a hissy-fight: Motorola.
Talking babies never stop being funny: E-Trade
Violin-playing beavers get to be in automotive hot tubs with beautiful women: Monster.com
Robots can get their feelings hurt if you talk about other, cooler technology (Intel). This will eventually lead to robots kidnapping you and trapping you inside the internets: Vizio
There are still pictures of hot women on the internet: GoDaddy
At long last, people are being arrested for using plastic bags: Audi
Men who are comfortable with themselves wash themselves: Dove
Men who are trying to be good boyfriends are spineless and should really be watching football: Flo TV
Men are willing to do anything, including eat fruit for breakfast and hear your friends' opinion of his friends, as long as they get to drive the car of their choice: Dodge Charger
Men Are Oafs. As usual, there are too many to list them all, but some examples include:
Men would fake their own deaths to watch a ball game (Doritos)
Men would give up their wives before their Bridgestone tires,
Men would rather drink Bud Light than be rescued off an island.
Men are only interested in books if Bud Light is involved (which, incidently, had the best line of the evening: "Do you like Little Women?" "Uh, yeah, I'm not too picky."
However, my favorite ad of the year was Google's, telling a romantic little tale via search queries:
It's nice to know that there is still time for some romance before the robots come to snatch us away.
5 comments
Petey
Who played?
Leonard Nolt
Although I didn’t watch it (I went to the movies to see “Up in the Air” instead - and it was very good) I appreciate your comments on the Super Bowl. I think there are things to be learned from that annual US obsession, perhaps as much from the audience as from the game. I wrote my own commentary on last year’s Supre Bowl on the blog The Cambium Level under the title Super BowL Perspectives which can be found at http://leonardnolt.blogspot.com/2009/02/super-bowl-perspectives.html.
My own criticism of sports has mellowed somewhat after seeing the positive effects of having a winning college football team in my home town of Boise, Idaho. The benefits do extend far beyond the realm of sports. It almost seems as if sports are the medium used today to bring people together in a joint energizing spirit of community and friendship. Although it might be better if this were done with a goal of improving our communties, helping marginalized people, or promoting literacy and education, rather than winning games, it’s certainly better than galvanizing around some currently designated common enemy such as bad-mouthing illegal aliens, targeting homosexuals or humanists, or even waging war against a poor country for the purpose of stealling resources. Thanks again.
Sincerely,
Leonard Nolt
Pat
I’m not usually one to knock the inspiring power of imaginary triumphs like New Orleans-over-hurricane-through-football, because I think that such things can have palpable real-world effects, but man, was that football coverage ever tiresome. Showing people devastated by the hurricane and then saying over and over again that all they need is for the Saints to finally win a Superbowl is just patently ridiculous and kind of offensive. I’m glad for New Orleans, and I’m sure it really will improve morale and even get more people to pay attention to the situation, but come on, people, this isn’t the last step of a New Orleans redemption story.
josh
no, the saints winning the super bowl will not reverse new orleans misforntunes. however, joy inspires hope, and that’s a very good thing. and pat, i feel ya, but if you’d have paid closer attention to all the coverage (and yes, it’s ever tireseom every year), they weren’t saying this was the final solution to new orleans’ problems, they were saying that after 5 years of struggle and rebuilding, new orleans finally has something to be really happy about. football, at least in new orleans, is the opiate of the masses, and i for one won’t begrudge them one bit if they get to feel high for a little while. : )
Fingtree
Thanks Payton Manning for taking one for the
City of New Orleans!! Payton is larger than life.
Most Recent Opinion Comments
Okay, almost 24 hours later and I finally got Issac’s Summer joke. I’m an idiot.
Swap the dog for a fire pit and it sounds like you’re writing about my back yard. Very nice.
And that, my friend, is love. Bob, I think I still owe you for my wedding cake, served in 1998. But nevermind.
I believe the kiss between Rob and I was documented on low-quality videotape in the mid-ninties porn classic, Dirty Harry…and Sticky.
Got damn, Coulter. You are the greatest.
Most Popular Opinion Articles (60 days)
- Feeling Hot, Hot, Hot!
- “Opposite” marriage includes fun, love, and drinking in the day

- I bet you wish you had a hat
- Politics and poker may or may not mix
- Priest suing N-G is part of Catholic splinter group
- Opening day brings drinks to the table
- Off the rails
- The desert
- A Modest-ish Proposal
- Double trouble in Coulter’s dog prison
Most Recent Comments
As a liberal conservative, and a person who favors taxes & services ... and also a sense of proportion; I savor the comic potential that still exists in this comments section. I’m pretty sure we can goad more anti-government rhetoric from confirmed progressives and government employees. If…
Did the Crave Truck get a permit to park in city metered spots and city right of way? Or did they just get a permit? The city clerk’s office seems to be a suspect here, but it’s not clear they did anything wrong. Did the Crave Truck…
it’s quite choice. looking forward to seeing how it and its patronage grow and develop over the course of the year. could be a neat little ecosystem.
“It was at this point, before he started his business, that working with city employees should’ve raised red flags…” But they didn’t because: 1) The City Clerk’s office originally mis-interpreted the rules, or are indeed re-interpreting them. 2) Champaign’s brick-n-mortar merchants hadn’t yet started whining about The Crave Truck.
Looking forward to trying this place!
I’m in the middle (or the beginning or end, depending on how you look at it) of re-reading Slaughterhouse Five. What a great companion column.
Get yours early. The Rave’s CD will be available at Exile and at The C-U Flea on Saturday. C-U Flea details here: http://www.smilepolitely.com/news/sp_radio_podcast_c-u_flea_arrives/
I don’t know about Gerard and a random police sargeant. My (mild) outrage is based on this: “...he worked closely with Champaign City Clerk Marilyn Banks to make sure he was licensed properly as a transient food peddler, filling out the necessary paperwork and paying a $225…
Local Yocal pretty much nails it here. I suspect there will be merchants who oppose food trucks because they arguably don’t pay their fair share to locate their trucks in high traffic (high rent) areas. The food trucks take away business from rent payers, park in city…
I also got to visit Big Grove Tavern during the soft open and definitely enjoyed the pork belly the most of all the dishes I sampled. The cheesy grits and the vinegary pickled vegetables were a perfect compliment to the rich pork belly.
The Alan Partridge lookalike on the right in the first small photo has nothing to condescend to anyone about. AH HA!
Snell and the little Hitlers of the neighborhood association need to chill out. Legitimate businesses should have the freedom to exist without having to endure the slings and arrows of ignorant and misguided opposition.
Yeah, I’d agree that Transporter Room 3 is the worst house venue I’ve ever seen.
Food trucks are the start-up, small businesses of the future for those unable to afford real estate. No surprise, that merchants who pay rent, utilities, and maintenance on a property would despise the traveling competition. Or developers who build more empty retail spaces would want to close…
Not so much far-right Tea Party as a balanced, moderate viewpoint between letting businesses succeed and protecting society with reasonable regulations. In spite of what the city reps are saying, the interpretation of policy on this issue certainly has changed. Letting a business start up under one…

Facebook
Twitter
Full Site
I’m in the middle (or the beginning or end, depending on how you look at it) of re-reading Slaughterhouse Five. What a great companion column.