Compromised reform
I'm a liberal. I believe in giving a little to try to make more people happy. I believe people's concerns should be taken into account if it will make for a stronger community. But I believe that compromise is warranted based on its effectiveness, not that it is a goal unto itself.
So, when I look at the current health care debate, I wonder why Democrats keep banging their heads against the wall of accommodation and compromise, when it clearly isn't going to make any difference.
Liberals believe our health care system is seriously broken. It has an infection, and the best way to fix this infection is to apply the antibiotics of a single-payer, universal health care system. This is how modern, civilized nations provide health care to their citizens.
Conservatives don't believe there is much of a problem in health care. Health care is properly handled by a byzantine collection of profit-making industries and rationed to those with access to good jobs. What little infection exists in our system they believe is best handled by applying more profit-sucking leeches to the skin of the system.
Compromise can happen when, say, one person likes one shade of color and another person likes a different shade of color. Both parties then work hard to find a third shade of color that they both can live with. Compromise cannot happen when one side likes one shade of color and the other side thinks color is evil.
So, compromise for health care reform is hard, because one side wants to use antibiotics and the other wants to use leeches. Nonetheless, Democrats compromised even before the discussion started by coming up with a plan to use half the recommended dose of antibiotics (in the form of a public, Medicare-like insurance option) along with the full number of leeches recommended by the Republicans (in the form of continuing with employer-based private insurance company plans).
Of course, Republicans are not happy with this, so the White House has now floated the idea of not using antibiotics at all, but using some co-op-based homeopathic, herbal remedy that scientists say won't work at all. Plus the full number of leeches the Republicans want.
Even before Democrats suggested the homeopathic remedy of the co-ops, it wasn't clear that the half-dosage of antibiotics was going to cure this patient, especially given the number of leeches attached to it. So, yeah, we're angry that the latest suggested compromise will likely kill the patient, which we believe to be an even worse solution than the leeches.
There's hope though. A few Democrats seem to have finally connected the dots, and determined that Republicans who have always been hostile to health care reform, and are still hostile to health care reform, will likely continue to be hostile to health care reform in the future. These Democrats seem ready to go forward without seeking Republican buy-in. In this case, that's a good thing.
Despite his lack of decorum, perhaps Barney Frank has the right general idea:
7 comments
I wish...
as an independent, I had the luxury of always “feeling” right b/c of my political affiliation. I wonder what that’s like. To have the DNC or RNC pretty much decide what I’ll think, and then rationalize it with myself by simply declaring I’m part of it. FannieFreddie have been funding the Barney Frank political machine for his entire career - even way back when he was running a prostitution ring from his house.
They are there to be regulated!! And don’t call me right-wing!!
I was at a meeting in Barney Frank’s office, back in the 20th century. I shook his hand afterwards. “Where are you from?“ he asked.
“Illinois,“ I confessed.
“I don’t care about your opinion” he responded. And I thought that was great. He keeps getting elected by a blue-collar southie (read: homophobe) constituency because he represents them well, and he listens to them.
I will never stop admiring him for being fearless, unapologetic, forthright.
I wish...
Rob, you’d address the FannieFreddie connection, because, since he is a US Congressman, I HAVE to care where he is from.
Patrick Gabridge
Barney Frank also gets elected from the over-educated liberal elite types in Brookline, where I live. I’m glad he’s my congressman. And I’m glad a few people are working to call the idiots on the right wing on their complete b.s.
Great post, Dan. I think you’re right, that if the Republicans don’t want to have a substantive debate around healthcare, then forget about them. It kills me that Obama was backing off the public option (of course, I really want a single-payer plan).
What'll happen...
when it goes even lower. People are waking up.
Or, we’re all getting more stupid, right?
http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/obama_administration/daily_presidential_tracking_poll
stuart
We’re certainly getting stupider if we believe anything coming out of right wing pollster Rasmussen. It’s the Fox News of polling.
Whatever...
I just randomly picked that poll - those stories are everywhere, just do a search, like I did, and click on a random poll. Fox = MSN. Olberman = O’reily. They even talk about each other on an almost daily basis.
Most Recent Opinion Comments
Curtis Orchard is always good for an hour or three, especially if you have rugrats.
eugh….I remember that sex ed class and i’m pretty sure I know the teacher you’re referring to. that place was hell.
Love the story about sex ed at the middle school. That’s what I do every day for my job—it’s so exciting to see students engaged in material many adults and parents assume is above their understanding or maturity level. Thanks for sharing! Oh, and if you…
“Rag Doll” by Aerosmith is a great accompanying song when you are throwing a tennis ball onto the floor to bother the people below you.
http://www.news-gazette.com/news/agriculture/2010-09-01/south-farms-taking-aim-birds-noise.html If U of I did any research into repelling birds, they would use a very silent but effective high output LASER instead of adding noise pollution to the already olfactory polluted area http://www.allpestco.com/2009/06/laser-bird-deterrent-or-laser-gun-vs-birds/
“I have some reading to catch up on, poolside.“ Classic.
What sticks in my neck is that most noise (unwanted sound) is a violation of the law. So why is it often so difficult to get the authorities to address the issue? Why are the anti-social elements so protected? These lowlife induviduals now seem to have the…
Spirit echoes - http://www.iainandjane.com/work/silentsound/index.shtml
People are entitled to peace and quiet. That gift has been lost and once lost is hard to regain. Anti-noise activitists fight for everyone’s right to have peace and quiet. Thanks to those that fight for our right to peace and quiet.
Most Recent Comments
Illinois has simply had no luck at all in these Mizzou games. None. I think maybe we’re do for a couple of bounces to go our way. If we get one or two (or sever or eight) breaks, I think it’s a win.
Jason, Savoy could easily join the CPL tax district, which is probably closer to most Savoy residents than the Tolono library is. But my impression is that Savoy residents as a whole don’t want to pay the cost of the CPL (Tolono’s library taxes are cheaper), even…
Sorry, but I am lagging behind on updates to the map. Also, some construction projects were delayed from their original start date. On a more positive note, I am putting together a map of haunted houses in Central Illinois. I have a few plotted already, and I…
I’ve never gotten the privilege of all the services CPL cardholders get. I just want to be able to go out of my way to drive to the CPL to check out books, pay fines, maybe buy some coffee, and enjoy the library. None of those activities…
These days, there is more to using a library than checking out books. At one time, paying into the Lincoln Trails system probably would cover the expenses incurred by other libraries in the system. Now, with Internet, videos, coffee shops, wireless Internet hubs, etc., I suspect the…
(speaking as a Savoy resident) By paying taxes to support a member of the LTLS, we are paying our “fair share” to use any LTLS library—Tolono, Champaign, Urbana, etc. This is how library systems work. The 6% of CPL’s circulation represented by Tolono users is NOT significant…
I read Timbo’s argument. I think the key word is “speculating.“
I would be interested to hear more about the “word on the street”—how are individual hauling companies fulfilling their promise to recycle?
Timbo makes a smart, sound argument. Reread it.
I joined on 09-09-09 after living here over a year, and having to listen to my dad tell me how his best friend is, like, #27 or something crazy like that, and how said friend never lived further than 50 feet from the Illini Inn while going…
And, I might add, no one is being prevented from using the Champaign library. They are just being asked to pay their fair share if they are going to use it as their primary library.
The equation is pretty simple here. If you want social services, then pay the taxes required to run those social services. These things only work if everyone puts in their fair share. As a heavy user of the Champaign Library, I say bravo to this new policy.
Curtis Orchard is always good for an hour or three, especially if you have rugrats.
What is the increased marginal cost of serving a resident of Savoy or Mahomet? I suspect negligible. What is the increased revenue to be realized by this new policy? I suspect very little. Aside from these financial aspects, what are the most probable results from this new…
Looks like you are also all members of the killer sideburns club.
Thanks for the article, Ben. I was not familiar with this band until now and even though I won’t be able to attend the show on Friday they are now on my radar. A *good* jam band is hard to find, and these folks appear to fill…
Nice article, love the Dead quote in the beginning. If they can get down here to Central FL I’ll definitely be heading out to the show. Some of my friends have finally stopped wincing when I say “jam band.“ I’ve now tried my best at more descriptive…
@Annie: Yeah, my bad. That was the best part! Drinking + memory exercises = fun @Rob: According to Ask the English Teacher, “My dictionary says ‘drunk’ is an archaic past tense of ‘drink.‘“ We’re all about the new grammar around here.
Katie, have the residents of Savoy and Tolono thought about having their taxes raised a little to help their public library expand? That’s a possibility for them. And then everybody wins.
good call on that Herring recording, Josh. Love that version of Exit Music….here’s a clip of the Cinco de Mayo show (from about six months prior). As I recall, this Shakedown went on for roughly a half hour, while getting into the Trampled Underfoot jam in the…
Most Popular Articles (14 days)
- Camp Rantoul Report: August 20, 2010
- Withershins: the hardest working band in Champaign
- Champaign to close recycling drop-off center
- Pygmalion schedule changes, Emeralds and new Erin Fein project added
- The Burlington Coat Factory Mosque
- Meet the new blog on the block
- CU Pride Fest review
- Flatlander fundraising off to a tasty start
- The right thing changes from state to state
- Garbage doesn’t just “go away”
Recent Searches
- 1592 (7 Results)
- Susan Toalson (3 Results)
- Gabe (4 Results)
- Bond (97 Results)
- Bond (97 Results)
- Gabe (4 Results)
- bond (97 Results)
- bond (97 Results)
- dan schreiber (34 Results)
- gillespie (129 Results)
- Men Against Sexual Violence MASV (1 Results)
- 8684 (1 Results)
- Men Against Sexual Violence MASV (1 Results)
- great cover up doug hoepker (13 Results)
- great cover up (589 Results)
- C-U Circle (32 Results)
- 4130 (1 Results)
- elsinore (123 Results)
- elsinore (123 Results)
- ryan groff elsinore (35 Results)
Facebook
Twitter
Full Site
Events Calendar
Sorry, but I am lagging behind on updates to the map. Also, some construction projects were delayed from their original start date. On a more positive note, I am putting together a map of haunted houses in Central Illinois. I have a few plotted already, and I…