iconLog In  |  Register

No humans were harmed during the making of this film

There is currently a lot of hub-bub and hoop-lah about James Cameron’s Avatar, an extraordinarily expensive sci-fi movie which arrived in theatres about two and a half weeks ago.  Since the initial trailer was released, people have been ‘freaking out’ over the visuals, the alien world of Pandora itself, and most sadly, the implied politics wrapped up in the films narrative.  I say implied because 1) the script makes no mention of any political party or affiliation, 2) the story takes place on a different planet, and 3) it’s a movie — you can’t vote it into office.  Seriously, if you think that by purchasing a movie ticket you are giving a mandate to the creators of the film, then watch out — depending on who you listen to, you may be simultaneously condemning the Bush-era, undercutting the American economy and re-electing Obama in 2012, just by attending.  But chillax people, it’s a film worth bringing your nephews and grandmothers to, not pitchforks and torches.

For those who have not seen the trailers, here’s a quick breakdown of the plot: ENRON survived, and they have spaceships. They send people to Endor, where instead of finding Ewoks they discover big blue cat-people with bows and arrows. This quickly turns into a PR nightmare. They need to mine rocks in the area but the indigenous folks keep killing them, so they bring in some scientists to study the land, commune with the natives, and make things go smoother. To facilitate communication between the scientists and the natives, Enron grows giant blue cat-people (“host bodies”) for humans to mentally inhabit, allowing them to walk amongst the natives (!!!). 

Trouble is, the natives think the scientists are weird, and don’t like hanging out with them (they suck at bows and arrows). Fate intervenes, and along comes a former marine. He is good at bows and arrows, and the natives choose to hang out with him some. Then John Wayne gets involved.  John Wayne is awesome — he’s tough, he’s direct, and he ‘takes care of his own’.  He’s job is to take care of security for the Enron employees, and so naturally he convinces the marine to feed him intel on the natives, suspecting he’ll eventually need to use it against them. The marine is suddenly living in two very different worlds, and the one he chooses to stay in will alter the fate of… the Universe!    

But get this; John Wayne is the bad guy. Later, he gets an arrow shot through his chest and two aliens make out on top of his corpse. No really.

Whether or not films are a product of our culture, or our culture is driven by the social messages represented in our films is hotly debated (by me I guess). But even though it takes place on a distant planet with a lot of giant blue cat-people, the plot of Avatar bears a striking resemblance to Earthly events of the last 500 years or so. Specifically; the birth of the United States. Really specifically; unpopular stuff that white people did to everybody else they encountered (honestly, if you identify yourself as Caucasian, check this movie out to see how Muslims feel when they watch True Lies, James Cameron’s film before Titanic). 

This creeping familiarity is there because the overall storyline is pretty hammy and unoriginal, but about 20 minutes in you’re not going to give a crap about all that.  You’ll be ‘ooh’ing and ‘ahh’ing all over the place. You’ll cheer for the good guys, even when they’re slaughtering what look like US infantry troops. You’ll likely get misty eyed a few times. And for Chrissakes, when was the last time you clapped at the end of a movie? Long story short; the film does have a message, and it goes something like this; we’re boned. Mankind is inevitably doomed to put the needs of our species above the needs of the planet, and that’s eventually going to ruin a lot of what we like about this place (trees). But there’s hope that it will end with Earth — that we won’t turn into Darth Vader’s Empire, drunkenly planet-hopping in search of better stuff. And if we do, maybe somebody will stop us.  See, the film is about hope, just not for any of us.   

Which righteously pisses off a lot of people. But if you hold the belief that humanity can do no wrong in its quest for survival, you’re not likely to be swayed by big blue cat-people. And if you just don’t like that the Democrats picked up the ‘green’ football before the Republicans did, then it’s okay to stay home, bide your time and then secretly rent Avatar when it comes out on DVD (as if it’s porn or something).  In any event, check it out, because in spite of it’s story and dialogue, Avatar is a stunning film worth everyone’s attention.

 

12 comments

Caleb Curtiss avatar featured_post

cdcurtiss

#1

As if it’s porn indeed…

username

Michael's Friend Cheryl

#2

wow, thats an altogether thoughtful and non-biased article…for a fascist.

Michael Curtin avatar featured_post

mcurtin

#3

Thank you Cheryl;your upgrading me from a ‘vacuous troglodyte’ to a mere ‘fascist’ is both thoughtfull and kind.
You’ll be happy to know that alternate titles for the article included ‘A white man’s fevered guilt fantasy’, and ‘Those cat-people should check out WebMD, because blue skin is often a sign of choking’.

username

Anon

#4

The real lesson of Avatar is that if the humans won and destroyed the cat people’s villages and moved them onto reservations so we could mine their land, we would eventually honor them by dressing up as cat-people mascots at football and basketball games, thereby making up for 500 years of cultural annihilation.

Rob McColley avatar featured_post

robmccolley

#5

Penn State does that.

Tyson avatar

Tyson

#6

Fern Gully

Michael Curtin avatar featured_post

mcurtin

#7

Here my take on Avatar 2; the ‘company’ comes back, and damnit they’ve grown an army of avatar’s.  So BAM!  You’ve got a Na’vi civil war of sorts on your hands.  Also; lazers. 

username

ron ton ton

#8

“A white man’s fevered guilt fantasy” was a MUCH better title. But then, that would’ve been a <a href=“http://io9.com/5422666/when-will-white-people-stop-making-movies-like-avatar”>better review</a>.

Michael Curtin avatar featured_post

mcurtin

#9

Nah.  I like my review more then the one linked above.  I think the weakness of the ‘white people need to see white people saving the world for everyone else’ argument is that both in reality and in narratives like Avatar, technology, not race, represents the real advantage that humans / white folks have over the indiginous groups.  Anytime an argument hinges on ‘well you know what they’re really talking about’, I get kinda suspicious.
Also, it’s yet another theory that puts white people in the ‘decider’ role (only as the source of the problem instead of the source of the solution).  This is not to say that James Cameron didn’t create a pretty silly and formuliac plot; rather my argument is why get worked up over it?  The answer is; you’re projecting your politics onto a movie, and whether you’re a democratic or a republican, that means you’re kind of missing the point (to have fun). 
 

emma reaux avatar featured_post

emma reaux

#10

Just saw this with a group of dudes. Also, there were several children sitting in my general vacinity. I felt this pressing urge to intervene and have a post-movie discussion with parents of the children, on how to process the gratuitous nipple shots and vague portrayal of blue-cat-people coitus. The little girl next to me, probably not even 7 years old, excliamed, “How romantic!“ during the mating scene. She kept repeating, “We have now mated for life” over and over, that is, until she started crying during the destruction of that tree thing and kept sobbing very loudly until the movie ended. Since I love nothing more than unnecessary computer-generated sex scenes (in 3D!), besides maybe confused and sobbing children, I’d give my overall movie-going experience 2 thumbs up!

username

Pat

#11

Well, Michael, I like the article a lot, but saying that it’s a movie informed by white guilt is not projecting our personal politics, it’s an analyzation of the form of the film. I understand that “projecting personal politics” can happen in analyses—like saying that Harry Potter is evil or The Hurt Locker is pro-war—but your argument would seem to be that these films cannot be analyzed from a politically-informed perspective, simply because their primary function might be to entertain us.
While you may be right about Avatar‘s basic purpose—to move, thrill, entertain, etc—even the notion of “entertaining” has political implications. What serves to move and entertain a large group of (often presum-edly white) spectators is political in and of itself: it is making a statement about what is fodder for entertainment and what narratives we find most pleasurable, a statement that can be revealing about popular culture and politics.
So there.

username

Pat

#12

Oh and not to mention the other political aspect of every film, which is related to the last: these films are made either by artists or by a committee of artists and execs, real-life people who do not live in a socio-cultural vacuum (I would argue that even living in such a vacuum gives you a specific and unique perspective on the world that could be called political). Thus, any film is the product of one or many ways of viewing the world, and anybody with any opinion about the way the world works or looks has a view with political implications.


Add A Comment

A note about our commenting policy.


Comment
  1.  captcha arrow

Most Recent Opinion Comments

{username}

I’ve always suspected that there’s a direct correlation between projected land use for the Rt 150 corridor [Industrial / Commercial] and the drive to expand 74. See the CCRPC Future Land Use Map for details, and then take a look at who owns land there, and you…

{username}

The University does not subsidize the Airbus. For decades bus transportation to the airport was provided expressly for Institute of Aviation students. This service was paid for by the Institute of Aviation, not campus as a whole. Some of you may even remember the old orange or…

{username}

A book just published gives a very useful different perspective on the “growth for growth’s sake” model and its ecological unsustainability. It is “Prosperity Without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet” by Tim Jackson. The first chapter of the book can be downloaded via http://earthscan.co.uk/pwg . This…

{username}

I agree with most of the comments on the Orange “Krush.“  They are mostly immature, ignorant, college students who can’t wait for the next frat party so they can get wasted on Keystone light

{username}

“Since there is no congestion on 74, one wonders what he is talking about.“ - Duh.  Perhaps the congestion is wishful thinking? And IL DOT is planning to spend $71 million taxpayer dollars widening I-74 between Champaign and Mahomet. I contacted IL DOT on the I-74 stuff. …

{username}

Great articles, btw.

{username}

Since 1994, the American Farmland Trust has had case studies which have shown that there is no net gain to developing farmland. On average the ratio of dollars generated by development to the cost of services provided by communities was $1 : $1.04. For farm land, the…

{username}

Stuart, Really a fantastic series of articles on this proposed road.  The Chinatown analogy is very cool.  I wouldn’t say that the local press has been lapdogs on this issue.  One of the local TV news channels actually did a piece where they interviewed Mr. Ziegler, the…

Seth Fein avatar

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/news/story?id=4961547   I stand by it all, except in that I should’ve used better language to describe the types of fools these folks are. Calling someone a douchebag, is kinda like, being a douchebag.   Strike that one from the record. Everything else, well, yeah…

Joel Gillespie avatar

Due to some unforeseen circumstances, part two will actually run Wednesday at 10 a.m. Thanks for your patience; it’ll be worth the wait!

Most Recent Comments

{username}

Pheidippides wasn’t planning on running a marathon; that’s why he died.  If he had known ahead of time that he’d be running 26 miles and followed a good training program for a year, stretched properly before the event, had bands and cheering people along the race route,…

John Steinbacher avatar

Doug, I absolutely agree. I think this might have come across focused on rock because, as you say, rock was the 90s, and we had some innovative rock bands here then. But what I’m really trying to get at is that there’s no way Dirty Projectors, Liars…

Doug Hoepker avatar

John, I’m not sure that the current climate for indie rock stardom is all that favorable for bands who simply rock out. Most of the bands doing it well that are also popular have been around for a while and have a tested identity (I’m thinking Spoon…

{username}

Keep us posted on the latter!

{username}

Nice article, Emily! When I get to the CU area, I’ll be sure to give this place a try.

Mica Swyers avatar

The marathon is certainly a tough distance, but I imagine that it compares to childbirth. In any event, having completed the former, I will agree that it is an excruciating tastk. Should the opportunity arise, I will let you know how the latter compares.

{username}

I’ve always suspected that there’s a direct correlation between projected land use for the Rt 150 corridor [Industrial / Commercial] and the drive to expand 74. See the CCRPC Future Land Use Map for details, and then take a look at who owns land there, and you…

Adam Fein avatar

Zelini, I really like this - I’ll try to follow the theory more closely. As they reveal more about Kate (possibly next week), it might give us more perspective.  I agree with your observation about Ben and I think Michael Emerson has done an excellent job conveying his lesser stature.

{username}

Surprised you think it will take two wins. I think we have a shot to get in with another loss.  The bubble is just a disaster this year, and we’ll float to the top even with one win.

{username}

What if the sideways alternatives are where Jacob actually grants them their wishes, but in ways they didn’t quite expect?  The elimination of one regret. Sayid gets to be with Nadia - although through his brother.  Maybe he ends up with her at the expense of his…

John Steinbacher avatar

The link has been updated. Thanks for alerting us.

Annie Weisner avatar

This also explains why I was starting to think Roses & Sake was a group of strange pagans from Vancouver.  This is when it pays to be a local.  My apologies to the true Roses & Sake, we’ll fix this ASAP!

Annie Weisner avatar

Ahh, shame on me.  I grabbed it directly off of Mike ‘N Molly’s website.  I’ll see if I can’t get it corrected on here (and maybe pass along the word to them as well).  Thank you, observant reader!

{username}

I’m with Brigham regarding the Acrylics set. Very XX-ish. Very good.

{username}

i think the roses & sake link is actually: http://www.myspace.com/rosesnsake  

Stef avatar

Dangit! Now I have to go home and try that cake. MMMmmMMMMmmmm looks goood. Cakey cakey cakey…

{username}

Very nice preview…I’m stoked to be seeing The Young Republic

{username}

I understood this totally differently than the other people that posted…this is what I got from it: - the more background you have going in, the more of the allusions you will understand when watching - afterwards, you can do a little research to fill in the…

{username}

Sorry about the lack of address and hours. All I can say is duuuh

Annie Weisner avatar

Amen.  When I told people I’ve lost 18 pounds since early October the number one response I get from women is concern.  18 pounds in four months is not unhealthy, quite the opposite for me.  But don’t give up on sugar, or become a vegan, or do…

Log In



Auto-login on future visits

Forgot your password?