iconLog In  |  Register

To Force or Not to Force

Posted in OPINION to Building a Sustainable Baby by Rose Marshack on Monday, October 20, 2008 at 8:00 am

metro9-23-00b.jpg

Two completely unrelated things

The Husband and I just had our first “date night” this year. We went to see Wire in Chicago at the Metro, the best place in all the US — and possibly Europe — to play a show. The stage is just a tad bit bouncy, perfectly sized so you can run back and forth on it and not run into anyone else, and the sightlines are fantastic; you can see almost anyone in the audience from anywhere on stage (if the lights are shining a certain way). At least you can see anywhere in the club.

Wire was great; I love a band that can write a song with one chord and have it be so complete and powerful. I believe this band is an important common denominator of all important punk rock 80s bands: the simplicity, the ferocity, the angst.

I’m going to talk about forcing your child to do something against his or her will today. I’ve had some discussions with friends, and there seem to be two camps: the “we’re not going to force our kid into doing something he or she won’t like” and the “who cares what the kid likes” camp. I fall into the latter, because this is how I was brought up.

Now bear in mind I’m talking about a four year-old. I don’t really have a lot of experience with older children. But what my experience across the board tells me is that pretty much no child wants to ever do anything but watch TV or play video games or surf the internet… or shop. Yes there is the odd kid who really does enjoy the violin lessons or the tennis lessons, but I think for the most part, if they had their druthers, most children would prefer to sit around and not be bothered by teachers or lessons.

So, if you want to be a counselor in my camp, your job would be to explain to the child that: 1) The lesson doesn’t last the entire day, it’s over pretty quickly, 2) “You’ll thank me for this later” (that never really goes over well), 3) You need to learn a skill like this because it will make you more powerful and able to learn better, 4) Being more powerful will get you more money, more friends, and more candy in the long run, and when all else fails, 5) You will get a candy bar after your lesson.

If you employ rewards, (and I can send you plenty of links that are adamantly opposed to this method), do so with the knowledge (or hope) that you should only have to do so for the first couple of weeks of lessons. The teacher should engage the student at least a month into the lessons, enough that the student feels challenged to improve his or her skills.

My personal opinion is that it’s bad to quit something the first year (or at least, half-year) that you’ve tried it, unless there are absolute glaring signs that the teacher or teaching methodology is bad. This is something that you’ll be able to tell yourself; if you watch your child and watch how the teacher engages your child, if there’s no match, then pull the plug. There are plenty of mediocre teachers around. There are also some incredibly amazing ones too.

Anyway, that’s my plug for forcing kids to learn things against their will. The Preschooler has been involved with a wonderful children’s martial arts class in town which required only three weeks of gum packages, musical instrument lessons (three sets, first set required four weeks of pleading and candy, second set which we only lasted a month in and decided it was terrible, and third set which is proving to require small rewards each week and is probably challenging The Preschooler to his absolute limit. And watching that is kind of my reward in itself.

I did thank my dad — 20 years into my “rock” career — for making me practice the piano all those years, from the stage of the Metro. He was there watching, and I could see him.

Add A Comment

A note about our commenting policy.


Comment
  4. captcha arrow

Most Recent Opinion Comments

{username}

Ok, just tell me when I can exhale - Just curious, since all the globalists, carbon traders, and pretty much anyone with copious amounts of wealth have weighed in on population reduction in recent years, i was wondering what yer magic number was. Some of the more…

Posted by Champ to the entry 'Students vote for a sustainable campus on 03/16/10.
Jeric avatar

Change is the only constant thing in this world. Change is just an indication that a particular place is improving or not. It is a good thing that there is a room for a change but it must be a change for the better. It is just…

Posted by Jeric to the entry 'A road in search of a reason on 03/14/10.
{username}

Now that Olympian is probably a given, they’re going to have to rename the section between Willow and 45. Any suggestions? Now lets get onto Urbana’s next road to nowhere. Airport Rd., They want to extend it from Bartlow west to Lincoln thru 3 farm fields. One…

Posted by also concerned to the entry 'A road in search of a reason on 03/14/10.
{username}

I had a great time reading around your post as I read it extensively.   Gold

Posted by Simon Dale to the entry 'Spring break confessions on 03/12/10.
{username}

I’ve always suspected that there’s a direct correlation between projected land use for the Rt 150 corridor [Industrial / Commercial] and the drive to expand 74. See the CCRPC Future Land Use Map for details, and then take a look at who owns land there, and you…

Posted by ConcernedCitizen to the entry 'A road in search of a reason on 03/11/10.
{username}

The University does not subsidize the Airbus. For decades bus transportation to the airport was provided expressly for Institute of Aviation students. This service was paid for by the Institute of Aviation, not campus as a whole. Some of you may even remember the old orange or…

Posted by Bill Ferguson to the entry 'The bus less traveled on 03/08/10.
{username}

A book just published gives a very useful different perspective on the “growth for growth’s sake” model and its ecological unsustainability. It is “Prosperity Without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet” by Tim Jackson. The first chapter of the book can be downloaded via http://earthscan.co.uk/pwg . This…

Posted by Gary Cziko to the entry 'Forget it, Jake. It's Champaign-Urbana on 03/08/10.
{username}

I agree with most of the comments on the Orange “Krush.“  They are mostly immature, ignorant, college students who can’t wait for the next frat party so they can get wasted on Keystone light

Posted by Illinois student to the entry 'Orange Krush simply an embarrassment on 03/04/10.
{username}

“Since there is no congestion on 74, one wonders what he is talking about.“ - Duh.  Perhaps the congestion is wishful thinking? And IL DOT is planning to spend $71 million taxpayer dollars widening I-74 between Champaign and Mahomet. I contacted IL DOT on the I-74 stuff. …

Posted by Tony C. to the entry 'A road in search of a reason on 03/04/10.
{username}

Great articles, btw.

Posted by Anna Barnes to the entry 'A road in search of a reason on 03/03/10.

Most Popular Opinion Articles (60 days)

  1. Orange Krush simply an embarrassment Posted to Opinion by Seth Fein on 02/12/10
  2. Bad theology is like bad breath featured_postPosted to Opinion by Ryan Neaveill on 01/21/10
  3. N-G redesign takes website from outdated to useless Posted to Opinion by Joel Gillespie on 02/10/10
  4. Lift the gavel on DUI Posted to Opinion by Seth Fein on 01/29/10
  5. Down with the R-word Posted to Opinion by Smile Politely Editors on 02/19/10
  6. Forget it, Jake. It’s Champaign-Urbana featured_postPosted to Opinion by Stuart Tarr on 03/01/10
  7. About that gavel… Posted to Opinion by Rob McColley on 02/18/10
  8. A road in search of a reason Posted to Opinion by Stuart Tarr on 03/03/10
  9. Maybe Right’s not so wrong Posted to Opinion by Cheryl Barnett on 01/28/10
  10. It’s time for the “Talk” Posted to Opinion by Smile Politely Editors on 02/12/10

Most Recent Comments

{username}

Joel, thank you for the opportunity to answer these questions and have them posted here. I really appreciate it! Yes, I was thrilled to see that Rep. Kucinich flipped today, so he will has committed to voting yes for health reform. I appreciated his comments which seem…

By Claudia Lennhoff to the entry 'Something is better than nothing on 03/17/10.
{username}

It appears to me that your reviewer did all that could be expected: she paid her money, saw the play and conveyed her impressions. The review (on the whole, laudatory) may have been rushed, in a generous attempt to publicize the production while it was still available…

By Stuart L. Albert--Library Specialist to the entry 'A review of "A History of the American Film" on 03/17/10.
{username}

Dan Schreiber’s chocolate is simply the best I’ve ever had.  It’s a whole different ball-game; closer to very high-end wine than anything out of Hershey PA. 

By Stuart Tarr to the entry 'Week Eight: The chocolate solution on 03/17/10.
{username}

That settles it… Im going.

By Bonzo to the entry 'Tied up in knots on 03/17/10.
{username}

Vosges is pretty decent chocolate, but you should definitely try the locally-produced chocolate from Dan Schreiber, available (regularly?) at Amara, Caffe Paradiso, and Common Ground.  I believe it is or will be at other places soon.

By Jason Brechin to the entry 'Week Eight: The chocolate solution on 03/17/10.
{username}

I read Kucinich flipped today. He must have read this and been convinced.

By Kt did to the entry 'Something is better than nothing on 03/17/10.
{username}

Bread Company can do some fantastic vegan dinner dishes!  Several of their pastas are vegan or could be made vegan and their pizzas can be ordered (and taste great) without the cheese.  I also recommend their roasted potatoes and their roasted garlic head appetizer.

By Zeleni to the entry 'The Bread Company delivers on its hummus on 03/17/10.
{username}

General Admission? Are we supposed to camp out the night before the game to get decent seats?

By Jeff to the entry 'NIT Ticket Info (Assembly Hall) on 03/17/10.
SFJon avatar

I wonder with Griffey if he’s not in game shape enough to play a significant number of minutes.  If you look at his minutes played this year, he’s never played a starters minutes.

By SFJon to the entry 'New Illini tradition? on 03/17/10.
Joel Gillespie avatar

I really appreciated Ms. Lennhoff’s candid answers to the questions. I learned a lot about health care reform from this experience. Thanks CCHCC!

By Joel Gillespie to the entry 'Something is better than nothing on 03/17/10.
{username}

Glad you asked Stuart. In the 1950s (well before they were approved for human use) poultry producers began using subtherapeutic doses of quinolone antibiotics, specifically fluroquinolone, to reduce the incidence of respiratory disease in overcrowded production conditions. In humans, quinolones are a last line of defense antibiotic…

By Anna Barnes to the entry 'Aioli, Mayonnaise — What's the difference? on 03/17/10.
{username}

Hah!  Good one, Joel.   But my question was a serious one.  I only buy eggs from a couple of local organic farmers, so I never thought about antibiotic-free eggs.  I’m assuming that Anna meant the hen was not fed antibiotics, but am not wholly sure. I’m…

By Stuart Tarr to the entry 'Aioli, Mayonnaise — What's the difference? on 03/17/10.
Joel Gillespie avatar

That sounds like a setup to a joke at a CSA’s annual banquet. Q: “How can you tell an antibiotic-free egg?“ A: “It just can’t seem to get rid of that cough.“ /shows self out

By Joel Gillespie to the entry 'Aioli, Mayonnaise — What's the difference? on 03/17/10.
{username}

First off did you read the wired magazine article I posted? You should. Second, WAS!? HAhahaaha. What, we aren’t being spied on right now. Its not legal anymore? Obama didn’t just re-authorize the patriot act? Semi-mythical deep packet inspection devices. Semi-mythical deep packet inspection devices. Semi mythical…

By HAHA to the entry 'UC2B Granted $22.5 Million, Champaign City Council Deciding Tuesday Whether to Accept Funds on 03/17/10.
{username}

I was all set to pounce on this, but it’s the truth.  There used to be bands in town I was afraid of, like I’d have a heart attack during their set.  There are still some great bands, but they’re pretty and dainty and low in cholesterol. …

By johnny to the entry 'Champaign Pop City on 03/17/10.
{username}

I love eating Vietnamese food, and having growing up my entire life eating it, I was excited to go.  I really wanted to like this place because of all of the hype I had heard——unfortunately, I was sorely disappointed.  I got the pho (vietnamese soup) and thought…

By Keeks to the entry 'Saigon to Bangkok in... Savoy on 03/16/10.
{username}

Kaiyo was decent for a sushi buffet, but it definitely isn’t as good as KO fusion.  I thought it was better than any sushi I’ve ever had at a chinese buffet, but was not as good as my least favorite sushi item at KO fusion.  However, I…

By Keeks to the entry 'Kaiyo a surprising delight for buffet on 03/16/10.
{username}

What is an antibiotic-free egg?  And how can you tell?

By Stuart Tarr to the entry 'Aioli, Mayonnaise — What's the difference? on 03/16/10.
{username}

Great article. I’ve always found that by making it in the blender, I can be my typical impatient self and pour tons of oil in at once. It’s very forgiving that way, though not fool proof. 

By Trey to the entry 'Aioli, Mayonnaise — What's the difference? on 03/16/10.
{username}

I will be at Danu this evening. And seeing as tomorrow - St. Pat’s - is my birthday, I will be celebrating with tons of green and fun!

By Endochick to the entry 'Your official St. Patrick's Day celebration guide on 03/16/10.

Most Popular Articles (14 days)

  1. All’s well, no worries, next year will be great! Posted to Sports by Rob McColley on 03/08/10
  2. Champaign Pop City featured_postPosted to Music by John Steinbacher on 03/12/10
  3. If You’re Bored, Then You’re Boring Posted to Culture by Beth D on 03/04/10
  4. Die another day Posted to Sports by Rob McColley on 03/12/10
  5. The Plastic Generation Posted to Culture by Joni Jeffries on 03/05/10
  6. Kaiyo a surprising delight for buffet Posted to Food & Drink by Emily Miller on 03/09/10
  7. “Nice flag, douchebag!“: one man’s quest to run as Lincoln Posted to Sports by Jeff Kohmstedt on 03/08/10
  8. Please take this mainstream argument and bury it Posted to Music by Troy Brundidge on 03/04/10
  9. A review of “A History of the American Film” featured_postPosted to Arts by Tracy Nectoux on 03/10/10
  10. Week Seven: The mug cake and the damage done Posted to Culture by gillian gabriel on 03/10/10

Recent Searches

  1. lost (461 Results)
  2. 1932 (1 Results)
  3. 1932 (1 Results)
  4. 1933 (1 Results)
  5. valentines (10 Results)
  6. allston (5 Results)
  7. allston (5 Results)
  8. schreiber (29 Results)
  9. tango (17 Results)
  10. 1687 (13 Results)
  11. steinbacher (2 Results)
  12. elsinore (95 Results)
  13. lost cu (378 Results)
  14. elsinore (95 Results)
  15. 1880 (1 Results)
  16. elsinore (95 Results)
  17. Thad Morrow (7 Results)
  18. Thad Morrow (7 Results)
  19. neoga blacksmith (26 Results)
  20. 1366 (1 Results)

Log In



Auto-login on future visits

Forgot your password?