The War on Tolerance, 2008 Update
What can be said about The War on Christmas® that hasn’t already been angrily shouted by Bill O’Reilly or snidely lampooned by Jon Stewart? Apparently, not much this year.
Christmas warrior James Dobson has had to recycle his list of sinful retailers that have the audacity to say “Happy Holidays” instead of “Merry Christmas.” The biggest news item so far seems to be a Utah state senator who wants to mandate encourage retailers to say “Merry Christmas.” Ho Hum. Yawn.
Is it possible that most people are finally tired of focusing on such a trivial non-issue? After all, The War on Christmas® was never about Jesus. It is about the rejection of separation of church and state. It is about intolerance of other religious traditions. It is about shopping.
And perhaps that’s the rub this year. This time around, The War on Christmas® is not being waged by retailers or atheists. It is being waged by Capitalism itself, which seems to be eating itself from within. This year, Capitalism is failing to provide many people with the opportunity to express their faith by shopping. And there’s no way O’Reilly or Dobson are going to go after Capitalism, after having lifted it up as a shadow god to Jesus for so long.
I recently saw God Grew Tired of Us, a documentary that follows Somali refugees who come to live in America, and their adjustment to American culture after growing up in internment camps. Their perspective on the Christmas season is quite poignant. For one, they are confounded by Christmas trees: “Yeah, it is a bit beautiful, but what is the meaning? Is it in the Bible?” asks one.
He goes on:
“Is Santa also in the Bible? And how does it connect with the birth of Jesus? You have so many things to use to celebrate the Christmas. What we have in Africa is also good, but ours is mainly celebrating the birth of Jesus Christ. That Jesus Christ is going to be born in our heart. So we have to prepare ourselves spiritually. Christmas Eve in Kakuma camp people march around the streets, dancing and singing.”
Notably missing from the Somali’s critique is any mention of offense from someone wishing them “Happy Holidays.”
In concentrating so hard on exclusion, O’Reilly and Dobson miss something fundamental about their own religion. Whether you believe Jesus is a wisdom teacher, political activist or God incarnate, celebrating his birth is not reduced one iota by which happy phrase you use to greet someone. What matters in following Jesus is providing hope to the hopeless, food to the hungry and clothes to the cold. It is speaking truth to power in love, advocating for the least among us, loving others as ourselves. It’s not about demanding that church nativities be placed in front of courthouses.
Some Christians that I think get it right are over at Advent Conspiracy:
They are not just doing the usual complaining that Christmas has turned into mass consumption. Instead, they advocate for the least among us, for economic justice. All rooted in Jesus’ message of compassion for all.
Nonetheless, the Christmas season is still young. There is plenty of time to publicly crucify some poor sap who believes in the separation of church and state or the inclusion of many religious traditions during this season of love.
I hold out hope that in our new post-Bush world, we’ve grown tired of this war, and perhaps, all wars.
6 comments
Yep. What Dan said.
Roger nehring
How naieve of you, you poor Mennonite sap(say, aren’t Mennonites usually socialists??). Dobson and O’Smiley are trying to SAVE CHRISTANITY, fer crissakes. You just don’t get it,do you the big picture, the secular humanist conspiracy to destroy The faith of the Founding Fathers(except for George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin—-never mind that now!)
Woe unto us unless every city hall lawn has a pink and pleasant plast(baby) Jesus.
I always thought socialism should be the natural economic system for Christians, who are supposed to share. I don’t know that most Mennonite agree with me, but I think they should.
But mostly, yes, may fire and brimstone rain down on any city hall that fails to appropriately honor Jesus by installing a pink and plastic nativity on its doorsteps.
Sam
Socialism entered into freely and voluntarily by the individual ought to be the economic choice of Christians. However, socialism imposed under the threat of force for noncompliance, that is not compatible with Christian theology.
Dan S
So, how is capitalism being forced on Christians any more compatible with Christian theology?
anna b
Dan: Each time I read and watch this it makes me cry. Thank you.
Most Recent Opinion Comments
hey, if hair ain’t gon’ be over your head, my jokes may as well be.
Okay, almost 24 hours later and I finally got Issac’s Summer joke. I’m an idiot.
Swap the dog for a fire pit and it sounds like you’re writing about my back yard. Very nice.
funny, as your summer begins, another Summer ends.
And that, my friend, is love. Bob, I think I still owe you for my wedding cake, served in 1998. But nevermind.
I believe the kiss between Rob and I was documented on low-quality videotape in the mid-ninties porn classic, Dirty Harry…and Sticky.
“Do I have to sign some forms, or am I just considered ‘in.’” You’re in!
Got damn, Coulter. You are the greatest.
I have no specific memory of it, but I wouldn’t be surprised if I’d kissed Mike, too—once we’d both drunk ourselves gay. And earlier this week I gave Clarence Shelley a back rub. Do I have to sign some forms, or am I just considered “in.”
Most Popular Opinion Articles (60 days)
- Feeling Hot, Hot, Hot!
- “Opposite” marriage includes fun, love, and drinking in the day
- I bet you wish you had a hat
- Politics and poker may or may not mix
- Priest suing N-G is part of Catholic splinter group
- Opening day brings drinks to the table
- Off the rails
- The desert
- A Modest-ish Proposal
- Double trouble in Coulter’s dog prison
Most Recent Comments
As a liberal conservative, and a person who favors taxes & services ... and also a sense of proportion; I savor the comic potential that still exists in this comments section. I’m pretty sure we can goad more anti-government rhetoric from confirmed progressives and government employees. If…
Did the Crave Truck get a permit to park in city metered spots and city right of way? Or did they just get a permit? The city clerk’s office seems to be a suspect here, but it’s not clear they did anything wrong. Did the Crave Truck…
High-profile whining. AKA Lobbying.
it’s quite choice. looking forward to seeing how it and its patronage grow and develop over the course of the year. could be a neat little ecosystem.
“It was at this point, before he started his business, that working with city employees should’ve raised red flags…” But they didn’t because: 1) The City Clerk’s office originally mis-interpreted the rules, or are indeed re-interpreting them. 2) Champaign’s brick-n-mortar merchants hadn’t yet started whining about The Crave Truck.
Super cool! Excellent track, Excellent band.
Looking forward to trying this place!
I’m in the middle (or the beginning or end, depending on how you look at it) of re-reading Slaughterhouse Five. What a great companion column.
Get yours early. The Rave’s CD will be available at Exile and at The C-U Flea on Saturday. C-U Flea details here: http://www.smilepolitely.com/news/sp_radio_podcast_c-u_flea_arrives/
I don’t know about Gerard and a random police sargeant. My (mild) outrage is based on this: “...he worked closely with Champaign City Clerk Marilyn Banks to make sure he was licensed properly as a transient food peddler, filling out the necessary paperwork and paying a $225…
Local Yocal pretty much nails it here. I suspect there will be merchants who oppose food trucks because they arguably don’t pay their fair share to locate their trucks in high traffic (high rent) areas. The food trucks take away business from rent payers, park in city…
Oh nice! I’d totally vote for Matt Campbell!
“Smile Politely sports writer announces candidacy for city government.”
I also got to visit Big Grove Tavern during the soft open and definitely enjoyed the pork belly the most of all the dishes I sampled. The cheesy grits and the vinegary pickled vegetables were a perfect compliment to the rich pork belly.
The Alan Partridge lookalike on the right in the first small photo has nothing to condescend to anyone about. AH HA!
Snell and the little Hitlers of the neighborhood association need to chill out. Legitimate businesses should have the freedom to exist without having to endure the slings and arrows of ignorant and misguided opposition.
represent, Matt.
Yeah, I’d agree that Transporter Room 3 is the worst house venue I’ve ever seen.
Food trucks are the start-up, small businesses of the future for those unable to afford real estate. No surprise, that merchants who pay rent, utilities, and maintenance on a property would despise the traveling competition. Or developers who build more empty retail spaces would want to close…
Not so much far-right Tea Party as a balanced, moderate viewpoint between letting businesses succeed and protecting society with reasonable regulations. In spite of what the city reps are saying, the interpretation of policy on this issue certainly has changed. Letting a business start up under one…
Facebook
Twitter
Full Site
I’m in the middle (or the beginning or end, depending on how you look at it) of re-reading Slaughterhouse Five. What a great companion column.